Food Options

Chef Jill cooks all of it here. Pick a package, pick your items, and we’ll handle the rest. Tap any heading to see what’s in it.

Reception Menu — $35/person

Buffet style. Includes starter + 2 entrees + 2 sides + bread.

À la carte appetizer, 60 person minimum

  • Veggies w/ Dill Dip or Hummus$3

  • Salsa w/ Tortilla Chips$3

  • Caprese Skewers$3

  • Peach Crostini$6

    Roasted peaches on whipped ricotta drizzled w/ honey

  • Caramelized Apple & Onion Crostini$6

    On flavored cream cheese

  • Bruschetta on Crostini$4

  • Hard Cider Cheese w/ Pretzel Breads$5

  • Spinach Artichoke Dip w/ Toasted Baguettes$5

  • Horseradish Roast Beef Crostini$6

  • Stuffed Mushrooms$5

  • Homemade Meatballs$6

  • Ceviche w/ Tortilla Chips$8

  • Shrimp Cocktail$8

Starter — choose 1

  • Garden Salad

    w/ 2 homemade dressings

  • Caesar Salad

  • Apple Harvest Spinach Salad

  • Ancient Grain Mediterranean Salad

Entree — choose 2

  • Herb Roasted Chicken

  • Herb Roasted Pork Tenderloin

  • Caprese Chicken

  • Beef Tips & Gravy

  • Baked Cheese Tortellini

  • Sausage Stuffed Shells

  • Hot Honey Pepperoni Pasta

  • Chicken Alfredo

Entree upgrade

  • Beef Brisket+$7

  • New York Strip+$7

  • 5oz Baked Salmon+$7

  • Seared Scallops (4)+$12

  • Shrimp Scampi+$10

  • Stuffed Smoked Chicken Bombs+$7

  • Shrimp Alfredo+$10

  • Seafood Boil+$12

Side — choose 2

  • Roasted Root Vegetable Blend

  • Garlic Roasted Red Potatoes

  • Bourbon Braised Brussel Sprouts

  • Wild Rice Pilaf

  • Garlic Mashed Potatoes

  • Jalapeno Creamed Corn

  • Roasted Sweet Potatoes

  • Macaroni & Cheese

  • Maple Glazed Carrots

  • Cavatappi Alfredo

  • Nut-Free Pesto Pasta

  • Au Gratin Potatoes

  • Creamed Spinach

  • Basket of Baynes Cornbread

    Bread — w/ flavored compound butter

  • Homemade Focaccia Bread

    Bread — ask about flavors

After-dinner dessert

  • Donut Hole Bar$4/person

  • Caramel Apple Bar$4/person

  • Chocolate Covered Strawberries$24/dozen

  • Baynes Cider Donuts$12.50/dozen

Beautiful Beginnings — $23/person

Brunch. Choice of 4 items.

  • Good Ole Scrambled Eggs

  • Apple Cinnamon Pancakes

  • Buttermilk Pancakes

  • Apple Scramble Pancakes

  • Apple Cinnamon or Fresh Berries French Toast

  • Traditional French Toast

  • Chicken Salad Croissants

    Events at store only

  • Chicken Salad Wraps

  • Frittata Stuffed Croissants

    Events at store only

  • Yogurt Parfait with Granola

  • World Famous Cinnamon Rolls

  • Bagels & Chef Jill's Flavored Cream Cheese

  • Corn Bread with Flavored Compound Butter

  • Home Fries

  • Creamed Spinach

  • Sweet Potato Hash

  • Assorted Homemade Sweet Breads

  • Warm Bread Pudding

  • Shakshuka

    Poached eggs w/veggies & tomato sauce

  • Frittata+$3

    Eggs, onions, bell pepper, cheese and sausage or ham

  • Applewood Bacon+$3

  • Cider-House Loaded Potatoes+$2

  • Canadian Bacon+$3

  • Breakfast Sausage+$3

    Traditional or turkey

  • Corned Beef Hash+$3

  • Breakfast Burritos+$3

  • Huevos Rancheros Casserole+$3

    Mexican black beans w/chorizo, egg & tomato

  • Additional Items$3/person per item

    Any additional item beyond your 4 choices

  • Baynes Cider Donuts$12.50/dozen

    Available August–April only

Luncheon Offerings — $23/person

Starter — choose one

  • Homemade Soup

  • Garden Salad

    homemade dressing

  • Caesar Salad

  • Caesar Pasta Salad

  • Mashed Potato Salad

  • Baynes Apple Slaw

  • Ancient Grains Mediterranean Salad

Sandwich — choose two

  • Pulled Pork Sliders

  • Sloppy Johnnys

  • BBQ Chicken Sliders

  • Chicken Salad Wraps

  • Chicken Salad Croissants

    events at store only

  • Brisket Sliders+$3

    Sandwich upgrade

  • Assorted Wraps+$3

    Deli meats

  • Hoagie Sub Assortment+$3

    Deli meats

  • Additional Soup or Sandwich$3/person per item

  • Additional Starter or Side$3/person per item

Side — choose one

  • Veggies & Dip

    includes Great Lakes chips

  • Maple Glazed Carrots

  • Jalapeno Creamed Corn

  • Seasonal Roasted Vegetables

  • Mac & Cheese

  • Cavatappi Alfredo

  • Nut-Free Pesto Pasta

  • Au Gratin Potatoes

  • Seasoned Crispy Rice

  • Chef Jill's Homemade Cornbread

Side option

  • Hoppin' John+$2

  • Grandma Arlene's Baked Beans+$2

  • German Potato Salad+$2

Power-Up Bowls — $24/person

Build-your-own bar. Choose 8 toppings + 2 dressings.

Base — choose one

  • Brown Rice

  • Quinoa

Protein — choose one

  • Ground Turkey

  • Ground Beef

  • Pulled Chicken+$3

    Protein substitute

Topping

  • Cottage Cheese

  • Roasted Sweet Potatoes

  • Black Beans

  • Garbanzo Beans

  • Tomato

  • Cucumber

  • Edamame

  • Red Onion

  • Diced Apple

  • Shredded Carrots

  • Beets

  • Hard Boiled Egg

  • Shredded Lettuce

  • Shredded Kale

  • Cheddar Cheese

  • Pepitas

  • Avocado

Dressing

  • Spicy Aioli

  • Vinaigrette

  • Hot Honey

  • Additional Toppings or Dressings$1/person per item

  • Additional Meat$6/person

Grazing Table / Charcuterie — $24/person

Meats, cheeses, fruits, veggies, dips, jams, crackers, breads, olives, pickles.

  • Warm Hard Cider Cheese w/ Pretzel Bread+$5/person

  • Hot Creamy Garlic Dip w/ Bread+$5/person

  • Shawn Loves His Smoker Dip+$5/person

    Warm

  • Chorizo Corn Dip+$5/person

    Warm

  • Bruschetta on Crostini+$5/person

  • Supreme Pizza Dip+$5/person

    Warm

  • Homemade Meatballs+$6/person

    Swedish, sweet & sour, or marinara

  • Ceviche with Tortilla Chips+$11/person

  • Bang-Bang Shrimp Dip+$11/person

  • Seafood Bake Dip+$11/person

  • Sweets (Chef's Choice)+$3/person

    May include mini s'mores, mini cookies, pie shooters, cheesecake shooters, chocolate dipped strawberries, PB filled dates, sweetbreads, buckeyes and more

Sliders & Sides & Such — $17/person

Choose 3.

  • Pulled Pork Sliders

  • Sloppy Johnny

    Our version of a Sloppy Joe, with Apple Bourbon BBQ sauce

  • Buffalo Chicken Sliders

  • BBQ Chicken Sliders

  • Chicken Salad Wraps

  • Apple Smash Burgers

    Events at store only

  • Chicken Salad Croissants

    Events at store only

  • Brisket Sliders+$3

  • Homemade Meatballs+$6

    Swedish, sweet & sour, or marinara

  • Additional Slider Choice$3/person per item

    Beyond your 3 choices

Side

  • Veggies & Dip$3/person

  • Maple Glazed Carrots$3/person

  • Jalapeno Creamed Corn$3/person

  • Homemade Mac & Cheese$3/person

  • Cavatappi Alfredo$3/person

  • Seasonal Roasted Vegetables$3/person

  • Nut-Free Pesto Pasta$3/person

  • Au Gratin Potatoes$3/person

  • Seasoned Crispy Rice$3/person

  • Grandma Arlene's Baked Beans$3/person +$2

  • Hoppin' John$3/person +$2

  • Great Lakes Chips+$2/person

    Add-on

  • Garden Salad$3/person

    Salad, homemade dressing

Salad

  • Caesar Salad$3/person

  • Caesar Pasta Salad$3/person

  • Mashed Potato Salad$3/person

  • Baynes Apple Slaw$3/person

  • Ancient Grains Mediterranean Salad$3/person

  • German Potato Salad$3/person +$2

Flaming Favorites — $23/person

Store events only. Choice of 2 grilled entrees + 2 sides.

  • Grilled Burgers

    Entree

  • Shawn's Famous Pulled Pork Sliders

    Entree

  • KERNS Grilled Beer Brats

    With onions and peppers

Entree

  • Koegel's Coney Dogs

  • Brisket Sliders+$5

  • Bone-In Grilled Chicken Breast+$3

  • Stuffed + Smoked Chicken Bombs+$3

  • Seafood Boil+$11

Side

  • Garden Salad

  • Caesar Salad

  • Caesar Pasta Salad

  • Mashed Potato Salad

  • Baynes Apple Slaw

  • Mediterranean Salad

  • Veggies & Dip

  • Cavatappi Alfredo

  • Maple Glazed Carrots

  • Seasoned Crispy Rice

  • Jalapeno Creamed Corn

  • Seasonal Roasted Vegetables

  • Au Gratin Potatoes

  • Nut-Free Pesto Pasta

  • Mac & Cheese

  • Hoppin' John+$2

    Side, black-eyed peas

  • Grandma Arlene's Baked Beans+$2

    Side

  • German Potato Salad+$2

    Side

  • Great Lakes Chips+$2/person

    Add-on

  • Additional Side+$3/person

Pasta Party — $18–20/person

Great for grads. $20/person for 0–99 people, $18/person for 100–150.

  • Cavatappi & Penne Pasta

    Two varieties included

Sauce — choose 3

  • Traditional Meat Sauce

  • Cheddar Cheese Sauce

  • Garlic Alfredo Sauce

  • Vodka Sauce

  • Marinara Sauce

Sauce option

  • Chicken Alfredo Sauce+$3

  • Hot Honey Pepperoni Sauce+$3

  • Sausage Stuffed Shells+$3

  • Shrimp Alfredo+$11/person

  • Garden Salad

    Includes 2 homemade dressings and croutons on side

  • Garlic Bread

    Included

Serves 50 — special add-on

  • Seasonal Fruit Bowl$200

  • Veggie & Dip Tray$150

  • Baynes Apple Slaw$75

  • Wood-Fired Pizza$18/pizza

    Minimum of 30 pizzas — special add-on

Fire-Kissed Pizza — $18/person

Minimum 100 people. Served with Garden Salad + bread sticks w/ marinara & ranch.

Crust choice

  • Homemade Crust

  • Gluten Free Crust+$3/pizza

Sauce choice

  • Marinara Sauce

  • Alfredo Sauce

Topping — choose up to 2

  • Smoked Brisket

  • BBQ Pork

  • Pepperoni

  • Bacon

  • Italian Sausage

  • Ham

Topping — unlimited

  • Bell Peppers

  • Onions

  • Mushrooms

  • Black Olives

  • Jalapeno

  • Elote Corn

  • Pepperoncini

  • Spinach

  • Pineapple

Drizzle choice

  • Maple Bourbon BBQ Drizzle

  • Spicy Aioli Drizzle

  • Truffle Oil Drizzle

  • Hot Honey Drizzle

  • Alfredo Drizzle

  • 3-Cheese Blend

    Standard on all pizzas

Additional/substitute cheese

  • Shaved Parmesan

  • Feta

  • Gouda

  • Vegan Cheese+$2/pizza

Hearty Harvest

Priced per entree. Entrees include a basket of bread with butter.

  • Chicken Pot Pie$18/person

  • Shepherd's Pie$22/person

  • Jambalaya$23/person

  • Hot Honey Pepperoni Rigatoni$18/person

  • Skillet Lasagna$18/person

  • Sausage Stuffed Shells$18/person

  • Brisket Stroganoff$22/person

  • Cornbread Upgrade+$2/person

    One-of-a-kind cornbread w/ compound butter, instead of bread basket

Add-on side

  • Garden Salad$3/person

  • Caesar Salad$3/person

  • Caesar Pasta Salad$3/person

  • Mashed Potato Salad$3/person

  • Baynes Apple Slaw$3/person

  • Seasoned Crispy Rice$3/person

  • Nut-Free Pesto Pasta$3/person

  • Mac & Cheese$3/person

  • Mediterranean Salad$3/person

  • Veggies & Dip$3/person

  • Cavatappi Alfredo$3/person

  • Maple Glazed Carrots$3/person

  • Jalapeno Creamed Corn$3/person

  • Seasonal Roasted Vegetables$3/person

  • Au Gratin Potatoes$3/person

  • Hoppin' John$3/person +$2

  • German Potato Salad$3/person +$2

  • Grandma Arlene's Baked Beans$3/person +$2

  • Great Lakes Chips+$2/person

    Add-on

Add-Ons for Any Package

Add to any food package.

  • Warm Hard Cider Cheese w/ Pretzel Bread$5/person

  • Hot Creamy Garlic Dip w/ Bread$5/person

  • Shawn Loves His Smoker Dip$5/person

    Warm

  • Chorizo Jalapeno Corn Dip$5/person

  • Bruschetta on Crostini$5/person

  • Supreme Pizza Dip$5/person

  • Nashville Hot Chicken Dip$5/person

  • Homemade Meatballs$6/person

    Swedish, sweet & sour, or marinara

Sweet Endings

Dessert. You choose, or leave it to Chef's Choice.

  • You Choose — 2 Desserts$10/person

  • You Choose — 3 Desserts$12/person

  • Chef's Choice Variety$6/person

    At least 2 desserts per person

Dessert choice

  • Pie Shooters

  • Apple Bourbon Bread Pudding

  • Chocolate Banana Bread Pudding

  • Assorted Cookies

  • Cinnamon Rolls

  • Mousse

  • Bourbon Dark Chocolate Pots de Crème

  • Brownies

  • Flavored Ice-Box Cakes

  • Mini Cheesecakes w/ Berries+$2

  • Caramel Apple Bar$4/person

  • Chocolate Drizzled Strawberries$24/dozen

  • Homemade Buckeyes$21/dozen

  • Donut Hole Bar$4/person

    Donuts and donut holes only available September–April

  • Infused Donut Holes$2/person

    4 donut holes per person

  • Baynes Cider Donuts$12.50/dozen

Prices are per person, before 6% sales tax and the service fee. A $500 minimum applies to all catering. See Policies & Pricing for the full picture.